Tuesday, February 16, 2010

Day 2 of the Withyman case

The case of David Withyman against Carenne Special School and its former teacher Anna Blackburn entered its second day of hearing before Judge Elkaim today.

The judge has allowed a three day adjournment as Mr Withyman has amended his claim and the Department of Education and Training needs time to go through and meet the amendments. While hearing this amendment, the department was given the opportunity to cross-examine Mr Withyman's solicitor Kristi McCusker. Counsel for the department asked who had been posting on this blog, which was successfully objected to by Counsel for Mr Withyman, Hugh Marshall, SC.

The judge encouraged Miss Blackburn, who is unrepresented before the court to seek assistance through the pro bono scheme during this time so she can be legally represented.

The case will resume on Monday.

72 comments:

Anonymous said...

Lets hope this means your blog will get published in the newspapers.

Anonymous said...

Great site, shows there is so much more to this school than just one teacher mucking around with a teacher. Lets hope this boy gets a positive outcome in court.

Anonymous said...

You got this before the bought and paid for media. Well done Julie.

Anonymous said...

I thought Julie was non-existant Neil.

Anonymous said...

Julie Brown fucked you all over snitches! I think Julie is probably Withyman's solicitor herself!

Anonymous said...

hello stranger crawled back out of the gutter

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Good luck Dave

Anonymous said...

Another conspiracy theory from Lee. Just like you and Michael with the hacker, the school being bugged, people breaking in, etc.

grubs said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

how could this happen to begin with. you should all be ashamed of yourselves.

Anonymous said...

When you see how they treat each other you can understand why they treat students the way they do.

It's very sad.

ringostar said...

When you have snitches like you on here you can understand why morale is low.

Anonymous said...

Lock them up and throw away the key

Anonymous said...

In typical govt style they are dragging this out so that the victim goes through more pain. The private sector would have settled to stop any impact on the victim and on the schools reputation. Instead they are going to let this drag the school and all its staffs name through the mud.

Anonymous said...

Let me guess who you are

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

No one has to quess who you are carennetruth the none other lee churches herself.

jrosenberg said...

things at carenne smell of covering up. staff were interorgated today by dept solicitors over things yet when complaints made nothing is done. they are in damage mode.

Anonymous said...

lucy(jrosenberg)why dont you let everyone on here know how you refuse to bring a certain student to the bus in a timely fashion EVERY thursday, (thats when you do bring him) everybody knows why you are doing it, to make the bus late so it is blamed on a driver. you dont care how you mess up peoples routines,you dont care how long the children sit on the bus you dont care about the children ,you are letting your own immature want to make trouble for a certain person overide your job description and the needs of the children. i would think that a person with a special needs son herself would have more regard and aptitude for people in the same position as you obviously i was wrong in thinking that. you act like a friend to everyone but you are no ones friend least of all the children and their families. you are not without any blame in regard to the state of carenne school

Anonymous said...

i am starting to wonder which one is worse lucy or carennetruth at the moment lucy is in the lead at least carennetruth doesnt bullshit exactly where she stands

hatho said...

Lucy just writes gutless anonymous letters to people and herself then gets sympathy and more work for it.

She is snitching everyone out.

Anonymous said...

i agree with you in that regard she is getting everyones guts and when shes called on it she dies in the ass

Anonymous said...

just like you jenny running information to parents you shouldnt be. you have trudy in your pocket dont you?

hatho said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

dont forget she is brian carters snitch too she has his number iun her mobile

hatho said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
jrosenberg said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ringostar said...

I have a prediction that by Saturday this site will be no more! What do you think DET Legal was doing?

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
hatho said...

I'm sure if you were being attacked like these bastards are doing to us you too would be fighting back. Carenne is a beautiful place that does good work, ruined only by a few people who have no idea.

The snitches are going to be exposed in time.

jrosenberg said...

mr plod was threatning carter today he say that he want to get transfer back to bathurst and he wont stop until he has got carter

Anonymous said...

Why the hell would Scott be at school when Simone wasn't even at work today you idiot - keep saying your fairy tails Lucy.

trudy n said...

i am not in jennys pocket i am in no ones pocket lucy dont you think that we are going to notice when our son is home so late you dont care that while you are already home our children are still travelling because of your thoughtlessness and selfishness you should have more consideration for the kids and their families its just a big joke to you isnt it . i have been called immature on this site for EVERYTHING i act in the best interest of my son and will continue to do so and if that makes me immature than so be it,i really dont care what i am called but i will not send my son if he could be in a situation that is dangerous to him i will not send my son to school when he is sick i will not send my son when the roads arent favourable for his travelling i make no apology for acting in the best interest of my son and nor should i have to i will not because you are a nobody in the scheme of things in my families life. carenne school is there to educate my son NOTHING MORE NOTHING LESS. i thought you were a decent person i was wrong how very disappointing

jrosenberg said...

im not lucy and i never said you were immature so get it right everyone at carenne knows how close you and the driver are

jrosenberg said...

anonymous you are a liar she came there round 2

Anonymous said...

Can you ever tell the truth

Anonymous said...

Why weren't you in your classroom Lucy?

jrosenberg said...

i was in photocopy and you couldnt not hear what they said

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

STOP SNITCHIN'

Anonymous said...

They don't know how not to. They are pathetic snitches who can't tell the truth. The snitches are going to be exposed!

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Yes you are lee and marg and lucy just two so far who will be exposed.

Anonymous said...

OK Jenny please expose us

Anonymous said...

Oh you will be exposed don't worry about that and it won't be jenny who does it.

jrosenberg said...

wake up jenny everyone know it is you on here saying things and getting trudy to back you. lucy has nothing to do with it stop set her up.

jrosenberg said...

trudy are you dum im not lucy and lucy is not holding up bus jenny is. her and jery sit there and hold up everyone else so they can say that lucy isnt bringing kids up shes a lier. youre in her pocket you made complaint to harvey becasue she said to you stick up for her so tell me you aint right

Anonymous said...

Everybody knows that Jake Rosenberg is Lucy Thornton. You have certainly bragged to enough people about it Lucy! It's just like saying carennetruth isn't Lee Churches

trudy n said...

When I post on this site you will know it because I will use my own name(unlike you).I have not posted on this site since 18th February.I have not spoken to Harvey about Jenny at all,I have only ever approached him (and he approached me)in the past about real issues that concerns my sons' education and well being.Anyway how do you even know when I have spoken to Harvey where is the confidentiality.You claim that you know exactly how the faeces got on the bus, but when asked you denied it and yet you say that enough is enough and you want it all to stop ,and its not fair to the kids, but the truth is you are quite happy for the the children to be subjected to such terrible conditions(i.e the faeces on the bus and the stench) by your continued silence.I dont think you do know,I think you like to be in the thick of it.Jenny doesnt need defending because she doesnt do anything wrong ,she does her job and quite proficiently I think .It stands to reason, doesnt it, that a parent might develop a rapport with the escort and driver, due to the fact, that they are transporting their kids to school everyday and they always arrive SAFE and HAPPY,what possible problem could you have with that,as if its any of your business(it does not mean that I am in anyones pocket as you claim, for you to misconstrue this so badly is reprehensible and childish)Why should i have to justify this association.As far as i am aware it is not Jennys job to bring students to the bus it is the aides job. I made a complaint to the principal because the bus was held up and my son didnt get home until 4.45.How foolish do you think I am,I am not dum ,far from it and can see exactly what you are doing, as can other people .Jenny and Gerry are lovely, decent people that deserve some respect,not the knives in their back, that you are so willing to inflict upon them.No-one is out of your scope of allegation,whether true or not,you do not distinguish, everybody will be attacked for no apparent reason other than your spite and shortcomings.Seems to me that what is lacking is some respect for each other and to treat others how you would like to be treated. FOR FUTURE REFERENCE THE FOLLOWING WORDS ARE SPELT LIKE THIS: LIAR(NOT LIER) DUMB(NOT DUM) BECAUSE(NOT BECASUE)INTERROGATED(NOT INTEROGATED)THREATENING(NOT THREATNING) and you call me dumb,typo or not get it right

Anonymous said...

Trudy these gutless trouble makers hide behind false names to crucify innocent people and bullie them because they to gutless to face the person face on, Ain't you Lee ,marg,michael,simonne,Lucy just to name a few of the gutless wonders ,But i will assure you all the end for you bullies is very near.

nedkelly said...

Jake Rosenberg is Lucy Thornton and is Peter Harvey's snitch.

Anonymous said...

When you make a complaint to Peter Harvey he usually discusses it with the principal, who tells Simone and the assistant principals. They of course can't keep it quiet.

jrosenberg said...

trudy i am not lucy get that right ok she was asked question about shit on the bus not me just because jenny makes up lie about who is who dont make them right. yes i know you spoke to harvey and there is no confident when you make allegation about people they tell people because they have right to know. everyone at carenne know you made crazy complaint about people. just like not sending son to school when his teacher away what do you think will happen. like lee say that just childish. you are in jenny pocket your rent here show that.

trudy n said...

where im my post did i name you nowhere no crazy complaints were made about anyone just because you say something doesnt make them right either if something is a worry to parents they have a right to question it (thats what makes us the parents )isnt that what the school has always told us is that if we have a concern come in and talk about it sounds to me that you are in everyones pocket lets get one thing straight as i have told you before i will do whats in the best interests of my son and will not check with you or anyone else i dont care what you think my family including my son were all doing fine all the years he wasnt attending school there and we will be fine after he has left there and all this will mean nothing to us with all that you say is going on up there cant you see how a parent would be worried if protecting my son makes me childish then so be it but then who the hell are you to judge me you are just an aide (you are a nothing)that is all you said you were asked about the shit on the bus and you were gonna tell and then you didnt they were your own words i wonder what lies you have told about me up there seeing as you dont even know me thats probably what you do to everyone up there in future when my husband and i have a concern about our son we will not see harvey at all we will make a decision ourselves on what we think we should do and you will know nothing but im sure you will make something up because THATS WHAT YOU DO you are so gutless you dont even use you own name and im suppose to listen to anything you have to say I DONT FUCKING THINK SO

trudy n said...

"you are in jenny pocket your rent here show that" wtf are you on about are you saying i pay jenny rent now you will make up anything wont you

Anonymous said...

You wouldn't know what she was saying. She is incoherrent and just think that is the kind of person they employ at Carenne to work as an aide with our kids. One that appears not to even be able to write properly!

I understand that she was a volunteer for a long time but how does that give you a job as a full-time aide when your skills are like this?

Anonymous said...

You are "lucy "jrosenberg" Lee Churches has told everyone you are and you report back to her what everyone is doing in the school you are a snitch thats how you got work all of a sudden by dobbing in your so called friends.hope you are proud of your self doing what you did to" barb" ,I hope she haunts you for the rest of your low life.

trudy n said...

anonymous 9.07 we arent allowed to ask questions pertaining to our kids otherwise we are seen as complainers its all fucked up we are shown no respect as parents of these children and we are supposed to just sit back and say "oh well" when the shit hits the fan and have stories made up about us they are totally untrue and to be badgered everyday by this bully on here it defies any normal logic

Anonymous said...

Trudy they want to think who pays there wages you the parents you are there bosses.No students no job.

Anonymous said...

Yes Jenny.

Anonymous said...

Taxes pay our wages you idiot.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous 7:40pm "LEE" Don't you think parents pay taxes you are the idiot.Parents keep there kids home you won't have a job.

Anonymous said...

Taxes pay our wages you idiot.

Anonymous said...

Trudy they want to think who pays there wages you the parents you are there bosses.No students no job.

Anonymous said...

Yes Jenny.

trudy n said...

where im my post did i name you nowhere no crazy complaints were made about anyone just because you say something doesnt make them right either if something is a worry to parents they have a right to question it (thats what makes us the parents )isnt that what the school has always told us is that if we have a concern come in and talk about it sounds to me that you are in everyones pocket lets get one thing straight as i have told you before i will do whats in the best interests of my son and will not check with you or anyone else i dont care what you think my family including my son were all doing fine all the years he wasnt attending school there and we will be fine after he has left there and all this will mean nothing to us with all that you say is going on up there cant you see how a parent would be worried if protecting my son makes me childish then so be it but then who the hell are you to judge me you are just an aide (you are a nothing)that is all you said you were asked about the shit on the bus and you were gonna tell and then you didnt they were your own words i wonder what lies you have told about me up there seeing as you dont even know me thats probably what you do to everyone up there in future when my husband and i have a concern about our son we will not see harvey at all we will make a decision ourselves on what we think we should do and you will know nothing but im sure you will make something up because THATS WHAT YOU DO you are so gutless you dont even use you own name and im suppose to listen to anything you have to say I DONT FUCKING THINK SO

Anonymous said...

When you make a complaint to Peter Harvey he usually discusses it with the principal, who tells Simone and the assistant principals. They of course can't keep it quiet.

Anonymous said...

lucy(jrosenberg)why dont you let everyone on here know how you refuse to bring a certain student to the bus in a timely fashion EVERY thursday, (thats when you do bring him) everybody knows why you are doing it, to make the bus late so it is blamed on a driver. you dont care how you mess up peoples routines,you dont care how long the children sit on the bus you dont care about the children ,you are letting your own immature want to make trouble for a certain person overide your job description and the needs of the children. i would think that a person with a special needs son herself would have more regard and aptitude for people in the same position as you obviously i was wrong in thinking that. you act like a friend to everyone but you are no ones friend least of all the children and their families. you are not without any blame in regard to the state of carenne school

Anonymous said...

No one has to quess who you are carennetruth the none other lee churches herself.